Guide · Shopify SEO

A merchant vanished from Google overnight. Here's what we found

This is the story of a job that's still going. I'm writing it now, before the happy ending, because the middle is the useful bit.

A trade wholesaler came to us after their web shop fell off Google. One week it was getting around 45 clicks a week from search. The next it was getting two. Nobody had touched the website. Nobody had been warned. The boss just knew the phone wasn't ringing off the website any more and nobody could say why.

First question: is it a penalty?

That's what everyone assumes. It almost never is. Google tells you in Search Console if a person at Google has penalised your site, under Manual actions. There was nothing there. No security issues either.

So nobody had punished the site. Google had simply looked at it, decided most of it wasn't worth showing, and quietly stopped. That's harder to fix than a penalty, because there's no form to fill in and nobody to say sorry to.

The autopsy

We pulled every page Google knew about and checked each one. About 1,200 pages in the sitemap. Google had indexed two of them. The homepage and the terms and conditions.

The rest fell into a few piles, and every pile came from the web shop the ERP supplied, not from anything the business had done.

  1. 1The same product lived at two addresses. One with a capital letter in the web address, one without. No tag telling Google which was the real one, so Google picked the old version, then decided neither was worth keeping.
  2. 2Pages that didn't exist said they did. Type in a made-up product code and you got a blank page with an "everything's fine" signal. Google calls that a soft 404, and a site full of them looks like a site full of junk.
  3. 3The sitemap was six months out of date. Every product dated the same day in spring. Google had no reason to come back and look.
  4. 4Around 2,000 manufacturer PDFs were open to Google. Identical files to every other stockist. Google was spending its visits on those, and picking a competitor's copy as the original.
  5. 5Most category pages had no words on them. Just a grid of products. Nearly three in four brand pages were completely empty.
  6. 6Product descriptions copied the title. On one bestseller, the description Google saw was the word "TEST".

The problem nobody spotted

None of this was the merchant's fault. They run a business. The web shop came bundled with the ERP that runs their stock, their accounts and their counter, and they trusted it to do the website properly too.

The hard part wasn't knowing what to fix. It was that most of the fixes weren't ours to make. They sat with the ERP provider's developers, in a queue, behind everyone else's jobs. Some took a week. Some are still waiting. That's the bit that hurts merchants most, and it's why I wrote about keeping the ERP but replacing the shop window.

What we fixed

We split it into what we could do ourselves straight away, and what we had to write up clearly for the developers so it actually got done.

  1. 1Canonical tags on every product and category, so each page tells Google which address is the real one.
  2. 2A redirect from every old capital letter address to the right one, done on the server by the merchant's own IT.
  3. 3A fresh sitemap that updates itself when a page changes.
  4. 4One line in robots.txt to stop Google wasting visits on the manufacturer PDFs.
  5. 5Proper written copy and FAQs on the category and brand pages that make the money, written for the trade, in our own words.
  6. 6Real descriptions on the 48 products people actually land on, from the manufacturers' datasheets.
  7. 7Bing, the Google Shopping feed (with barcodes), and pages AI tools can read, so the business wasn't relying on Google alone while it recovered.

What didn't work

Request Indexing, the button in Search Console everyone tells you to press. We pressed it a lot. Twenty six category pages, all freshly rewritten, all checked first. Google came and looked at every one of them. It indexed none.

That told us something useful. The pages weren't being ignored because Google hadn't seen them. They were being held back because Google didn't trust the site as a whole yet. You can't button press your way out of that. So we stopped, and put the time into things that build trust instead: better pages, fewer junk pages, and links from the brands they stock.

Where it is now

Honestly? Not fixed yet. Google's category impressions went from thousands a month in July to almost nothing in October, and they haven't come back. The homepage has partly recovered. Most of the shop is still sat in "Crawled, currently not indexed".

But here's what's interesting. While Google sulked, AI tools kept going. Visits from ChatGPT and similar tools doubled from September to October, and they now name this wholesaler for some of its products. Google Shopping is putting its stock in front of people too, without needing the pages indexed at all.

I'll write the next part when the numbers move. If they don't, I'll write that instead.

If this is happening to you

Before anyone touches anything, do these in order. Most of them take ten minutes.

  1. 1Check Manual actions in Search Console. If it's empty, it isn't a penalty. Stop panicking about that.
  2. 2Open the Pages report and look at the biggest reason pages aren't indexed. That's your starting point, not a guess.
  3. 3Type a made-up product code into your own website. If you get a blank page instead of a proper "not found", you've got soft 404s.
  4. 4Open your sitemap and look at the dates. If everything says the same day months ago, Google thinks nothing has changed.
  5. 5Count how many of your category pages have no words on them. Be honest.
  6. 6Find out which of these you can fix yourself and which sit with your platform provider. That second list tells you how stuck you really are.
Common questions

Why did my website suddenly disappear from Google?

Usually it isn't a penalty. Google has decided most of the site isn't worth showing, often because of duplicate addresses for the same page, pages that don't exist returning a normal page, an out of date sitemap, or lots of pages with no real content. Search Console's Pages report shows which one is biggest.

How do I know if Google has penalised my site?

Open Search Console and go to Manual actions. If a person at Google has penalised the site, it says so there. If it says no issues, the drop is Google's systems deciding not to show the pages, not a penalty.

Does Request Indexing fix pages that aren't indexed?

It gets Google to look at a page again. It doesn't make Google index it. If pages are crawled but not indexed across a whole site, the issue is trust in the site as a whole, and pressing the button won't change that.

How long does it take to come back after a Google drop?

Technical fixes can be done in weeks, but Google has to recrawl and rebuild trust, which takes months on a site it has gone cold on. Meanwhile Google Shopping, Bing and AI tools can still send buyers.

Free Revenue Snapshot

Not sure which one's costing you most?

If your web shop has dropped off Google and nobody can tell you why, send me the link. I'll look at what Google actually thinks of it and tell you straight whether it's fixable where it is, or whether the platform is the problem.

Get your free Revenue Snapshot→